Winter at Stadacona and the Cedar Cure
- Written
- events of December 1535 to April 1536; printed 1545
- Place
- Stadacona, and the French fort on the Sainte-Croix River
- Language
- French
- Kind of source
- travel account
- Reading time
- 6 minutes
- Difficulty
- Moderate
- Intensity
- Medium: the symptoms of scurvy and the deaths of sailors are described plainly; the opening of a dead man's body is cut
First contact in the AmericasNortheast WoodlandsDoctors and medical ideasFood, farming and hunger
Two women of Stadacona went out with the French captain and came back with nine or ten branches. They showed the sailors how to grind the bark and leaves, boil them in water, drink the water, and lay the pulp on swollen legs. Within days the French had stripped a whole tree.
Jacques Cartier, a ship’s captain from Saint-Malo, sailed up the St. Lawrence River in 1535 for King Francis I of France, with three ships and about 110 men. He spent the winter beside Stadacona, an Iroquoian town on the site of Quebec City, whose chief was Donnacona. The river froze, and snow lay more than four feet deep. Then scurvy struck, a disease caused by a lack of vitamin C. The sailors were living mostly on salted and dried food, with no fruit or vegetables. Twenty-five of them died before the spring.
Nobody then knew what caused scurvy. The French believed the sickness had passed to them from the people of Stadacona. They turned to prayer, and they cut open a dead sailor’s body to look for the cause, in a passage left out here. What happened in the town they knew only from what its people told them. They talked with Domagaya, Donnacona’s son, through signs and through the French he had learned in France.
The account was written by Cartier or by someone on board; who wrote it is not known. It was printed in Paris in 1545, with a dedication to King Francis I. The writer was there, and he writes in praise of the captain. The text here follows a copy of a sixteenth-century manuscript, printed at Quebec in 1843. The 1545 printing differs in a few small details, given in the footnotes.
Watch for who gets the credit for the cure: the Virgin Mary and God, or Domagaya and the two women. Notice also what the captain hides from his hosts, and why. In early May, Cartier seized Donnacona, his two sons, and several others and carried them to France.
The edited translation, in simplified modern English. Bracketed words were added for clarity; [...] marks a cut. Tap a note number to read the note.
The Sickness at Stadacona and in the Fort
In December we learned that a mortality1 had struck the people of Stadacona.2 By their own account, more than fifty of them had already died. So we forbade them to come to our fort, or anywhere near us.3 But even though we had chased them off, the mortality broke out among us too, in an astonishing way, and of a kind no one knew. Some lost all their strength, and their legs grew thick and swollen, and the sinews drew tight and turned black as coal. On some, the legs were spotted all over with drops of blood, purple in color. Then the sickness climbed up into the hips, thighs, shoulders, arms, and neck. In everyone the mouth grew so foul and rotten at the gums that all the flesh fell away down to the roots, and nearly all the teeth fell out. The sickness took such a hold in our three ships that by the middle of February, of the 110 men we were, not ten were healthy. No one could help anyone else. It was a pitiful thing to see, given where we were. Every day the people of the country came in front of our fort and saw few of us on our feet. Already eight were dead, and we had given up hope for the lives of more than fifty others.
Our captain saw our misery and how the sickness had spread, and he set everyone to praying. He had an image of the Virgin Mary taken over the snow and ice and set against a tree, a bowshot from our fort. He ordered that Mass be said there on the following Sunday. All who could walk, sick or well, were to go in the procession and sing the seven Psalms of David4 with the Litany.5 They were to pray the Virgin to ask her dear Child to have pity on us. After the Mass was said and sung before the image, our captain made a vow. If God gave him the grace to return to France, he would go as a pilgrim to Our Lady, who is prayed to at Rocquemadou.6 That day Philippe Rougemont died, a native of Amboise, about twenty years old.
[...] The people of the country came near our fort, and we had to hide the sickness from them. So our captain, whom God always kept on his feet,7 went out to meet them. He took two or three men with him, some well and some sick, and had them follow him out. Once they were outside the enclosure, he pretended he wanted to beat them. He shouted and threw sticks after them and sent them back on board. He showed the Savages8 by signs that he kept his men working inside the ships. Some were calking9 and others making bread or doing other jobs, and it was no good for them to come idling outside. And they believed it. The captain also had the sick men inside the ships bang and make noise with sticks and stones, pretending to calk. By then we were so stricken by the sickness that we had nearly given up hope of ever seeing France again. But God in his endless goodness and mercy looked on us with pity. He let us learn of a remedy against all sicknesses, the most excellent ever seen or found on earth, as we will tell in the next chapter.
The Tree Called Annedda
[...] One day our captain saw the sickness spreading so and his men so badly stricken by it. He had gone out of the fort and was walking on the ice. He saw a band of people coming from Stadaconé, and among them was Domagaya.10 Ten or twelve days before, the captain had seen him very sick with the very same sickness his men had. One of his legs was as thick as a two-year-old child, with all its sinews drawn tight. His teeth were lost and ruined, and his gums rotten and foul. When the captain saw Domagaya healthy and cured, he was overjoyed. He hoped to learn from him how he had been cured, so he could bring help and relief to his men. When they reached the fort, the captain asked him how he had cured his sickness. Domagaya answered that he had cured himself with the juice and the pulp of the leaves of a tree, and that this was the one remedy for this sickness. Then the captain asked if there was any of it nearby. He asked Domagaya to show him some to cure his servant, who had fallen sick in the house of Lord Donnacona.11 He did not want to tell him how many of his companions were sick. Then Domagaya sent two women with our captain to fetch some. They came back with nine or ten branches. They showed us that we had to grind the bark and leaves of this wood and boil it all in water. Then the sick were to drink the water every other day and put the pulp on their swollen, sick legs. They said this tree cured every sickness. In their language the tree is called Annedda.12
Right away the captain had the drink made for the sick. Not one of them wanted to try it, except one or two who took the risk. The moment they drank it, they felt the good of it, and this turned out to be a true and plain miracle. After two or three drinks they were cured of every sickness they had, and their health came back. One of the companions had had the pox13 for five or six years before this sickness, and he was cured cleanly by this medicine. After seeing this, the men pressed so hard for the medicine that they nearly killed one another to be first to get some. So a tree as thick and as tall as any tree I ever saw was gone in less than eight days.14 It worked wonders. If every doctor in Louvain and Montpellier had been there with every drug in Alexandria,15 they could not have done as much in a year as this tree did in eight days. It did us so much good that everyone who was willing to use it got back health and was cured, thanks be to God.
Notes
- The writer’s word for a deadly outbreak. The disease he goes on to describe among the French was scurvy, caused by a lack of vitamin C. The sickness at Stadacona is usually taken to be scurvy too. back
- An Iroquoian town on the site of Quebec City, below the cliff, whose chief was Donnacona. Cartier’s ships lay close by, in the Sainte-Croix (now the Saint-Charles River). back
- The French feared contagion: the idea that disease passed from person to person by touch, breath, or objects, long before anyone knew about germs. Scurvy does not pass between people. back
- The seven penitential psalms (Psalms 6, 31, 37, 50, 101, 129, and 142 in the Latin Bible of the time), long recited as prayers of sorrow for sin. back
- A prayer of many short requests, each answered by the people, used especially in times of disaster. In prayer books of the time the Litany of the Saints followed the seven psalms. back
- Rocamadour, a shrine of the Virgin Mary in the Quercy region of southern France, one of the most famous places of pilgrimage of the later Middle Ages. back
- Or “whom God always kept from harm.” The French debout (standing) can go with either part of the sentence; either way, the captain stayed well. back
- The writer’s word, Sauvages. The French used it for the Native peoples of America; it also meant people of the forest. back
- Hammering fiber into the seams of a ship to make it watertight. back
- A son of Donnacona. He and his brother Taignoagny had spent about eight months in France after Cartier’s first voyage, learned French, and came back with him as guides. back
- Donnacona, the chief of Stadacona. back
- Which tree this was is disputed. Eastern white cedar has long been the usual answer; others have proposed white spruce, white pine, hemlock, or balsam fir. The 1545 printing spells the name Ameda. back
- La vérole, a word for diseases that leave sores on the skin. The 1545 printing has la grosse vérole, “the great pox,” the usual French name for syphilis. back
- The 1545 printing says the tree was as big as any oak in France and was used up in six days. back
- Louvain (Leuven, in modern Belgium) and Montpellier, in southern France, had universities with faculties of medicine, and Montpellier’s was famous across Europe. Alexandria in Egypt was the great market where Europeans bought spices and drugs from the East. back
Au mois de Décembre fumes avertis que la mortalité s'estoit mise au peuple de Stadacona, tellement que jà en estoient morts par leur confession plus de cinquante. A cause de quoi, leur fimmes défenses de non venir à notre Fort, ni entour nous. Mais nonobstant les avoir chassés, commença la mortalité entour nous d'une merveilleuse sorte, et la plus inconnue.
In the month of December [we] were warned that the mortality had set itself on the people of Stadacona, so that already of them were dead, by their confession, more than fifty. Because of which, [we] made them prohibitions not to come to our Fort, nor around us. But notwithstanding having chased them [away], the mortality began around us in a marvelous [astonishing] manner, and the most unknown.
In December we learned that a mortality had struck the people of Stadacona. By their own account, more than fifty of them had already died. So we forbade them to come to our fort, or anywhere near us. But even though we had chased them off, the mortality broke out among us too, in an astonishing way, and of a kind no one knew.
- The writer’s word for a deadly outbreak. The disease he goes on to describe among the French was scurvy, caused by a lack of vitamin C. The sickness at Stadacona is usually taken to be scurvy too.
- An Iroquoian town on the site of Quebec City, below the cliff, whose chief was Donnacona. Cartier’s ships lay close by, in the Sainte-Croix (now the Saint-Charles River).
- The French feared contagion: the idea that disease passed from person to person by touch, breath, or objects, long before anyone knew about germs. Scurvy does not pass between people.
Car les uns perdoient la soutenue, et leur devenoient les jambes grosses et enflées, et les nerfs retirés, et noircis comme charbon, et aucunes toutes semées de gouttes de sang, comme pourpre. Puis montoit la dite maladie aux hanches, cuisses, espaules, au bras et au col. Et à tous venoit la bouche si inefcte et pourrie par les gencives que toute la chair en tomboit jusqu'à la racine des dents, lesquelles tomboient presque toutes.
For some lost their support [strength?], and their legs became big and swollen, and the sinews drawn back, and blackened like coal, and some [legs] all sown with drops of blood, like purple. Then the said sickness climbed to the hips, thighs, shoulders, to the arm and to the neck. And to all [of them] the mouth became so infected and rotten by the gums that all the flesh fell from it down to the root of the teeth, which fell out almost all.
Some lost all their strength, and their legs grew thick and swollen, and the sinews drew tight and turned black as coal. On some, the legs were spotted all over with drops of blood, purple in color. Then the sickness climbed up into the hips, thighs, shoulders, arms, and neck. In everyone the mouth grew so foul and rotten at the gums that all the flesh fell away down to the roots, and nearly all the teeth fell out.
Et tellement s'esprit la die maladie en nos trois Navires, qu'à la mi-Fevrier, de cent-dix hommes que nous étions il n'y en avoit pas dix sains, tellement que l'un ne pouvoit secourir l'autre, qui estoit chose piteuse à voir, considéré le lieu où nous estions ; car les gens du pays venoient tous les jours devant notre Fort, qui peu de gens voyoient debout, et jà y en avoit huit de morts, et plus de cinquante où on espéroit plus de vie.
And so much did the said sickness take hold in our three Ships that at mid-February, of a hundred and ten men that we were, there were not ten healthy, so that the one could not help the other, which was a pitiful thing to see, considering the place where we were; for the people of the country came every day before our Fort, who saw few people standing, and already there were eight dead, and more than fifty in whom one hoped [no] more for life.
The sickness took such a hold in our three ships that by the middle of February, of the 110 men we were, not ten were healthy. No one could help anyone else. It was a pitiful thing to see, given where we were. Every day the people of the country came in front of our fort and saw few of us on our feet. Already eight were dead, and we had given up hope for the lives of more than fifty others.
Notre Capitaine voyant la pitié et maladie ainsi esmeue, fit mettre le monde en prières et oraisons, et fit porter une Image et remembrance de la Vierge Marie contre un arbre, distant de notre Fort d'un traict d'arc, le travers les neiges et glaces, et ordonna que le Dimanche ensuivant l'on diroit au dit lieu la Messe, et que tous ceux qui pourroient cheminer tant sains que malades, iroient à la procession, chantans les sept Psaulmes de David, avec la Litanie, en priant la dite Vierge qu'il luy plust prier son Cher Enfant qu'il eust pitié de nous : et la Messe dite et chantée devant la dite Image, se fit le Capitaine Pélerin à Nostre Dame, qui se fait de prier à Rocquemadou ; promettant y aller, si Dieu luy donnoit grace de retourner en France. Celuy jour trépassa Philippe Rougemont, natif d'Amboise, de l'âge d'environ vingt ans.
Our Captain, seeing the pity [misery] and sickness thus stirred up, had the people put to prayers and orisons, and had an Image and likeness of the Virgin Mary carried against a tree, distant from our Fort by a bowshot, across the snows and ices, and ordered that on the following Sunday Mass would be said at the said place, and that all those who could walk, healthy as well as sick, would go to the procession, singing the seven Psalms of David, with the Litany, praying the said Virgin that it might please her to pray her Dear Child that he have pity on us: and the Mass said and sung before the said Image, the Captain made himself a Pilgrim to Our Lady, who is prayed to [?] at Rocquemadou; promising to go there, if God gave him grace to return to France. That day died Philippe Rougemont, native of Amboise, of the age of about twenty years.
Our captain saw our misery and how the sickness had spread, and he set everyone to praying. He had an image of the Virgin Mary taken over the snow and ice and set against a tree, a bowshot from our fort. He ordered that Mass be said there on the following Sunday. All who could walk, sick or well, were to go in the procession and sing the seven Psalms of David with the Litany. They were to pray the Virgin to ask her dear Child to have pity on us. After the Mass was said and sung before the image, our captain made a vow. If God gave him the grace to return to France, he would go as a pilgrim to Our Lady, who is prayed to at Rocquemadou. That day Philippe Rougemont died, a native of Amboise, about twenty years old.
- The seven penitential psalms (Psalms 6, 31, 37, 50, 101, 129, and 142 in the Latin Bible of the time), long recited as prayers of sorrow for sin.
- A prayer of many short requests, each answered by the people, used especially in times of disaster. In prayer books of the time the Litany of the Saints followed the seven psalms.
- Rocamadour, a shrine of the Virgin Mary in the Quercy region of southern France, one of the most famous places of pilgrimage of the later Middle Ages.
Left out of this excerpt.
Left out of this excerpt.
Et pour couvrir la dite maladie lorsqu'ils venoient près de notre Fort, notre Capitaine, que Dieu a toujours préservé debout, sortoit au devant d'eux avecque deux ou trois hommes tant sains, que malades, lesquels il faisoit sortir après luy; et lorsqu'il les voyoit hors du parc, faisoit semblant de les vouloir battre, et criant, et leur jettant bâtons après eux, les envoyant à bord, montrant par signes ès dits Sauvages qu'il faisoit bésogner ses gens dedans les Navires : les uns à gallifester, les autres à faire du pain et autres besognes, et qu'il n'estoit pas bon qu'ils vinssent chomer dehors : ce qu'ils croyoient. Et faisoit le dit Capitaine battre et mener bruit ès dits malades dedans les Navires avec bâtons et cailloux, feignans gallifester: Et pour lors estions si épris de la die maladie, qu'avions quasi perdus l'espérance de jamais retourner en France, si Dieu par sa bonté infinie et miséricorde ne nous eust regardé en pitié, et donné connoissance d'un remède contre toutes maladies, le plus excellent qui fut jamais vu ni trouvé sur la terre, ainsi que nous dirons dans le chapitre suivant.
And to cover the said sickness when they came near our Fort, our Captain, whom God has always preserved standing, went out before them with two or three men, healthy as well as sick, whom he made go out after him; and when he saw them outside the enclosure, [he] made as if to want to beat them, and shouting, and throwing sticks after them, sending them aboard, showing by signs to the said Savages that he made his people work inside the Ships: some at calking, the others at making bread and other tasks, and that it was not good that they should come idling outside: which they believed. And the said Captain made the said sick men inside the Ships beat and make noise with sticks and stones, pretending to calk: And at that time [we] were so taken by the said sickness that [we] had almost lost the hope of ever returning to France, if God by his infinite goodness and mercy had not looked on us in pity, and given knowledge of a remedy against all sicknesses, the most excellent that was ever seen or found on the earth, as we shall tell in the following chapter.
The people of the country came near our fort, and we had to hide the sickness from them. So our captain, whom God always kept on his feet, went out to meet them. He took two or three men with him, some well and some sick, and had them follow him out. Once they were outside the enclosure, he pretended he wanted to beat them. He shouted and threw sticks after them and sent them back on board. He showed the Savages by signs that he kept his men working inside the ships. Some were calking and others making bread or doing other jobs, and it was no good for them to come idling outside. And they believed it. The captain also had the sick men inside the ships bang and make noise with sticks and stones, pretending to calk. By then we were so stricken by the sickness that we had nearly given up hope of ever seeing France again. But God in his endless goodness and mercy looked on us with pity. He let us learn of a remedy against all sicknesses, the most excellent ever seen or found on earth, as we will tell in the next chapter.
- Or “whom God always kept from harm.” The French debout (standing) can go with either part of the sentence; either way, the captain stayed well.
- The writer’s word, Sauvages. The French used it for the Native peoples of America; it also meant people of the forest.
- Hammering fiber into the seams of a ship to make it watertight.
Left out of this excerpt.
Un jour notre Capitaine voyant la maladie si émue, et ses gens si fort épris d'icelle, estant sorti hors du Fort, et soy promenant sur la glace, apperçut venir une bande de gens de Stadaconé, en laquelle estoit Domagaya, lequel le Capitaine avoit veu depuis dix ou douze jours fort malade de la propre maladie qu'avoient ses gens: car il avoit l'une de ses jambes aussi grosse qu'un enfant de deux ans, et tous les nerfs d'icelle retirez, les dents perdues et gâtées, et les gencives pourries et infectes.
One day our Captain, seeing the sickness so stirred up, and his people so strongly taken by it, having gone out of the Fort, and walking on the ice, saw coming a band of people from Stadaconé, in which was Domagaya, whom the Captain had seen ten or twelve days before very sick with the very sickness that his people had: for he had one of his legs as big as a child of two years, and all the sinews of it drawn back, the teeth lost and spoiled, and the gums rotten and infected.
One day our captain saw the sickness spreading so and his men so badly stricken by it. He had gone out of the fort and was walking on the ice. He saw a band of people coming from Stadaconé, and among them was Domagaya. Ten or twelve days before, the captain had seen him very sick with the very same sickness his men had. One of his legs was as thick as a two-year-old child, with all its sinews drawn tight. His teeth were lost and ruined, and his gums rotten and foul.
- A son of Donnacona. He and his brother Taignoagny had spent about eight months in France after Cartier’s first voyage, learned French, and came back with him as guides.
Le Capitaine voyant le dit Domagaya sain et guéri fut fort joyeux, espérant par lui sçavoir comme il s'étoit guéri, à fin de donner aide et secours à ses gens. Et lorsqu'ils furent arrivez près le Fort, le Capitaine lui demanda comme il s'estoit guéri de sa maladie : lequel Domagaya repondit, qu'avec le jus des feuilles d'un arbre, et le marc, il s'estoit guéri, et que c'étoit le singulier remède pour cette maladie. Lors le Capitaine demanda s'il y en avoit point là entour, et qu'il lui en montrast pour guérir son Serviteur qui avoit pris la dite maladie en la maison du Seigneur Donnacona : ne lui voulant déclarer le nombre des Compagnons qui estoient malades. Lors le dit Domagaya envoya deux femmes avec notre Capitaine pour en querir, lesquelles en apportèrent neuf ou dix rameaux, et nous montrèrent qu'il falloit piler l'écorce et les feuilles du dit bois, et mettre le tout bouillir en l'ean, puis boire de la dite eau de deux jours l'un, et mettre le marc sur les jambes enflées et malades, et que de toutes maladies le dit arbre guérissoit ; et s'appelle le dit arbre en leur langage Annedda.
The Captain, seeing the said Domagaya healthy and cured, was very joyful, hoping to know through him how he had cured himself, in order to give aid and help to his people. And when they had arrived near the Fort, the Captain asked him how he had cured himself of his sickness: which Domagaya answered, that with the juice of the leaves of a tree, and the marc [pulp], he had cured himself, and that it was the singular remedy for this sickness. Then the Captain asked if there was any of it round about, and that he show him some of it to cure his Servant who had taken the said sickness in the house of Lord Donnacona: not wanting to declare to him the number of the Companions who were sick. Then the said Domagaya sent two women with our Captain to fetch some, who brought nine or ten branches of it, and showed us that one had to grind the bark and the leaves of the said wood, and put the whole to boil in water, then drink of the said water every other day, and put the marc on the swollen and sick legs, and that the said tree cured all sicknesses; and the said tree is called in their language Annedda.
When the captain saw Domagaya healthy and cured, he was overjoyed. He hoped to learn from him how he had been cured, so he could bring help and relief to his men. When they reached the fort, the captain asked him how he had cured his sickness. Domagaya answered that he had cured himself with the juice and the pulp of the leaves of a tree, and that this was the one remedy for this sickness. Then the captain asked if there was any of it nearby. He asked Domagaya to show him some to cure his servant, who had fallen sick in the house of Lord Donnacona. He did not want to tell him how many of his companions were sick. Then Domagaya sent two women with our captain to fetch some. They came back with nine or ten branches. They showed us that we had to grind the bark and leaves of this wood and boil it all in water. Then the sick were to drink the water every other day and put the pulp on their swollen, sick legs. They said this tree cured every sickness. In their language the tree is called Annedda.
- Donnacona, the chief of Stadacona.
- Which tree this was is disputed. Eastern white cedar has long been the usual answer; others have proposed white spruce, white pine, hemlock, or balsam fir. The 1545 printing spells the name Ameda.
Tot-après le Capitaine fit faire du breuvage pour faire boire ès malades, desquels n'y en avoit nul d'eux qui voulut icelui essayer, sinon un ou deux qui se mirent en aventure d'icelui essayer. Tot-après qu'ils en eurent bu ils eurent l'avantage, qui se trouva être un vray et évident miracle. Car de toutes maladies de quoy ils estoient entachés, après en avoir bu deux ou trois fois, recouvrèrent santé et guérison ; tellement que tel des Compagnons qui avoit la vérole puis cinq ou six ans auparavant la dite maladie, a esté par la dite médecine curé nettement. Après ce avoir vu, y a une telle presse qu'on se vouloit tuer sur la dite médecine à qui premier en auroit : de sorte qu'un arbre aussi gros et aussi grand que je vis jamais arbre, a esté employé en moins de huit jours; lequel a fait telle opération, que si tous les médecins de Louvain et Montpellier y eussent esté avec toutes les drogues d'Alexandrie, ils n'en eussent pas fait tant en un an, que le dit arbre a fait en huit jours. Car, il nous a tellement profité, que tous ceux qui en ont voulu user ont recouvert santé et guérison ; la grâce à Dieu.
Soon after, the Captain had the drink made to give the sick to drink, of whom there was none of them who wanted to try it, except one or two who ventured to try it. Soon after they had drunk of it they had the advantage [benefit], which turned out to be a true and evident miracle. For of all sicknesses with which they were stained, after having drunk of it two or three times, [they] recovered health and cure; so that one of the Companions who had had the pox for five or six years before the said sickness has been cleanly cured by the said medicine. After having seen this, there is such a press that people wanted to kill each other over the said medicine, [as to] who would have some first: so that a tree as big and as tall as I ever saw a tree has been used up in less than eight days; which has had such an effect that if all the doctors of Louvain and Montpellier had been there with all the drugs of Alexandria, they would not have done as much in a year as the said tree has done in eight days. For it has profited us so much that all those who were willing to use it have recovered health and cure; thanks to God.
Right away the captain had the drink made for the sick. Not one of them wanted to try it, except one or two who took the risk. The moment they drank it, they felt the good of it, and this turned out to be a true and plain miracle. After two or three drinks they were cured of every sickness they had, and their health came back. One of the companions had had the pox for five or six years before this sickness, and he was cured cleanly by this medicine. After seeing this, the men pressed so hard for the medicine that they nearly killed one another to be first to get some. So a tree as thick and as tall as any tree I ever saw was gone in less than eight days. It worked wonders. If every doctor in Louvain and Montpellier had been there with every drug in Alexandria, they could not have done as much in a year as this tree did in eight days. It did us so much good that everyone who was willing to use it got back health and was cured, thanks be to God.
- La vérole, a word for diseases that leave sores on the skin. The 1545 printing has la grosse vérole, “the great pox,” the usual French name for syphilis.
- The 1545 printing says the tree was as big as any oak in France and was used up in six days.
- Louvain (Leuven, in modern Belgium) and Montpellier, in southern France, had universities with faculties of medicine, and Montpellier’s was famous across Europe. Alexandria in Egypt was the great market where Europeans bought spices and drugs from the East.
Who and what this source names, in the original. Each name links to every source in the library that mentions it. Not yet checked.
Ideas
- Annedda The Iroquoian name of the tree whose bark and leaves cured Cartier's men of scurvy in 1536. Which tree it was is disputed; eastern white cedar is the usual answer. Sections 17.2.
- Contagion The idea that disease passed from person to person by touch, breath, or objects, long before anyone knew about germs. Sections 15.1.
- Doctors and healers Doctors, surgeons and other healers: what the writers say they could and could not do. Sections 17.3.
- Epidemic, plague, pestilence The words the writers themselves used for an epidemic: Greek loimos and nosos, Latin pestis, pestilentia and mortalitas, Chinese 疫 yi, Japanese 疫瘡 "epidemic sores". Sections 15.1.
- Scurvy A disease of long voyages and winters on salted food, with swollen legs and rotting gums. Its cause, a lack of vitamin C, was unknown at the time. Sections 15.2, 17.1.
People
- Domagaya A son of Donnacona who had spent about eight months in France and learned French. In 1536 he showed the French the annedda remedy that had cured him. Sections 17.1, 17.2.
- Donnacona Chief of Stadacona. Cartier seized him in May 1536 and took him to France, where he died, probably in 1539. Sections 17.2.
- God The one God worshiped by Jews, Christians and Muslims. Many writers in the library saw his hand in epidemics, cures, voyages and the fortunes of colonies. Sections 15.4, 15.7, 17.3.
- Jacques Cartier Navigator of Saint-Malo who sailed to the Gulf and River of St. Lawrence for Francis I of France, and wintered beside Stadacona in 1535–1536. Sections 15.4.
- Philippe Rougemont A sailor from Amboise, about twenty years old, who died at the French fort beside Stadacona during the sickness of 1535–1536. Sections 15.4.
- The Virgin Mary Mary, the mother of Jesus. Catholics prayed to her to ask her son for mercy, and honored her at shrines such as Rocamadour. Sections 15.4.
Places
- Alexandria The great port city of Egypt, founded by Alexander the Great. In the 1500s it was the market where Europeans bought spices and drugs from the East. Sections 17.3.
- Amboise A town on the Loire River in France, home of the young sailor Philippe Rougemont, who died at Stadacona in the winter of 1535–1536. Sections 15.4.
- France The kingdom whose kings sent Cartier and Champlain to the St. Lawrence and claimed the lands they explored. Sections 15.4, 15.7.
- Louvain (Leuven) A town in the Low Countries with a university and a faculty of medicine, named by Cartier's writer beside Montpellier as a home of learned doctors. Sections 17.3.
- Montpellier A city in southern France whose university faculty of medicine was famous across Europe. Sections 17.3.
- Rocamadour A shrine of the Virgin Mary in the Quercy region of southern France, one of the most famous places of pilgrimage of the later Middle Ages. Cartier vowed to go there if he came home safely. Sections 15.4.
- Stadacona, and the French fort on the Sainte-Croix River An Iroquoian town on the site of Quebec City, below the cliff, whose chief was Donnacona. Cartier's ships wintered close by, in the Sainte-Croix (now Saint-Charles) River, in 1535–1536. Sections 15.1, 17.1.
Page images of the original object or of the printed edition, from the libraries and archives that hold them. The pages shown are copied here where the holder marks them public domain; titles link to the holder's own viewer. Click a page to see it full size.
Voyages de découverte au Canada, Quebec 1843 (reprinted 1927)
Internet Archive (University of Pittsburgh Library System). pp. 56–60 (image numbers n63–n67). Public domain (published 1843, reprinted 1927); Internet Archive: not in copyright.
The printed edition our text follows, read against these page images.
Bref récit et succincte narration de la navigation faite en MDXXXV et MDXXXVI, Paris: Tross, 1863
Internet Archive. The chapters on the sickness and the cure. Public domain (published 1863).
A reprint of the Paris printing of 1545, used to compare readings.
Other translations of this passage. Links go to copies that are free to read online.
John Florio (from Ramusio’s Italian), 1580. English. Public domain.
The whole voyage, translated through the Italian. It turns the image of the Virgin into an image of Christ and calls the tree Ameda or Hanneda.
A Memoir of Jacques Cartier, Sieur de Limoilou (New York: Dodd, Mead, 1906)
James Phinney Baxter, 1906. English. Public domain.
The whole second voyage, translated from the French, with notes.
H. P. Biggar, 1924. English. Public domain.
The whole second voyage, with the French text of a Paris manuscript facing the translation, the readings of the other manuscripts and of the 1545 printing, and notes.
Difficulty: Moderate, a clear story with some period religious terms; the notes explain the prayers and the tree.
Fits these units
- Food, farming, and Native knowledge. What did Europeans learn from Native farmers, cooks, and healers, and how did they describe it?
- Violence, disease, and blame. Whom did writers blame for the suffering that followed contact?
Key terms
- mortality
- a deadly outbreak of disease, in which many people die
- scurvy
- a disease caused by a lack of vitamin C
- contagion
- the spread of disease from person to person
- Mass
- the main act of worship in the Catholic Church
- vow
- a solemn promise, here one made to God
- pilgrim
- a person who travels to a holy place as an act of faith
- calking
- hammering fiber into the seams of a ship to keep the water out
Questions
- Comprehension
What did Domagaya and the two women show the French to do with the branches of the tree called Annedda?
- Analysis
The writer calls the cure “a true and plain miracle” and thanks God for it, but he also tells how Domagaya and the two women taught it. How does he fit these two explanations together, and why might he tell the story of the cure this way?
- Analysis (reliability)
The writer was with the French that winter, but his name is not known, he writes in praise of the captain, and the account was printed in 1545. Which parts of the passage could he know firsthand, and which did he learn from the people of Stadacona? How should that shape what we trust?
- Connection
Read The Sickness That Followed the English (Harriot). Harriot reports that people began to die soon after the English left towns that had plotted against them, while none of the English died, and that some of them thought the English God was killing them. The French at Stadacona believed the sickness had passed to them from the town. Compare how each group explained where a sickness came from, and whom each account leaves to blame.
Activity
Students build a timeline of the winter from the text (the news in December, the count by the middle of February, the Mass and the vow, the captain's pretense, Domagaya's visit, the cure). On each entry they note who acted and what explanation the writer gives. They then write two captions for the cure, one in the writer's terms and one that names only what the text shows Domagaya and the women did, and compare them.
A printable worksheet for this source · More on Hearth Learning
New translation from the French text of the second voyage printed by the Literary and Historical Society of Quebec in Voyages de découverte au Canada (Quebec, 1843), pages 56–60, read in the Society’s reprint of 1927. The Society printed a copy of a sixteenth-century manuscript in Paris. About two-thirds of the three chapters on the sickness (chapters 15–17): chapter 15 without the opening of a dead sailor’s body and the burials in the snow, and all of chapter 17. Chapter 16, on the ice and the number of dead, is left out. The Society’s notes are not translated.
Where the Paris printing of 1545 differs on a fact, the footnotes give its reading. The writer’s long sentences joined by “and” are broken up. His word Sauvages is kept as “Savages,” and his place names are kept as he spells them.
- Original
- Text as printed in the named edition or on the object, read from page images. Edition: Voyages de découverte au Canada, entre les années 1534 et 1542, par Jacques Quartier, le sieur de Roberval, Jean Alphonse de Xanctoigne, etc. (Quebec: William Cowan et fils, for the Literary and Historical Society of Quebec, 1843; reprinted 1927), “Second voyage,” chapters 15 and 17, pp. 56–60. The Society printed a copy of the oldest of three manuscripts of the second voyage in the royal library in Paris, collated with the other two and with Lescarbot and Ramusio (its foreword). Digital text: Internet Archive item voyagesdedcouv13alfo (University of Pittsburgh copy of the 1927 reprint), OCR text, extracted by code and read against the page images. The Society’s notes are not copied. Author’s text only.
- Transliterated
- Not needed: the original is in the Latin alphabet
- Close English
- Close translation drafted by Claude (Anthropic), kept as a working draft
- Simplified English
- Drafted by Claude (Anthropic) from the original and checked unit by unit against the original in a separate review, then compared with earlier translations and tested for borrowed wording.
- Editor’s review
- Not yet.
- Specialist review
- Not yet. Readings a specialist should confirm are listed for later review.
- Rights
- Original: public domain. Edition: being checked. Our translations and notes: CC BY-SA 4.0; credit “Hearth Library, hearthinteractive.com” with a link.
Sources for the notes
- Voyages de découverte au Canada, entre les années 1534 et 1542. Quebec: Literary and Historical Society of Quebec, 1843; reprinted 1927. Foreword (“Avertissement”) and pages 56–60, with the Society’s notes on those pages. Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/voyagesdedcouv13alfo
- Cartier, Jacques. Bref récit et succincte narration de la navigation faite en MDXXXV et MDXXXVI. Paris: Tross, 1863. A reprint of the 1545 printing; the chapters on the sickness and the cure. Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/brefrcitetsuccin00cart
- Biggar, H. P., ed. and trans. The Voyages of Jacques Cartier. Publications of the Public Archives of Canada 11. Ottawa: F. A. Acland, 1924. The dedication to Francis I and its notes, pp. 85–86; notes on Stadacona and on Domagaya and Taignoagny, pp. 122–125; the sickness and the cure, pp. 204–215, with the readings of the manuscripts and of the 1545 printing and the editor’s notes (on the seven psalms, the Litany, Rocamadour, the annedda, Louvain and Montpellier). Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/voyagesofjacques0000cart_f4g3
- Baxter, James Phinney. A Memoir of Jacques Cartier, Sieur de Limoilou. New York: Dodd, Mead, 1906. Preface, and the chapters on the sickness and the cure with the notes, pp. 190–197 (on Rocamadour and the annedda). Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/memoirofjacquesc00baxt
- Hakluyt, Richard. The Principal Navigations, Voyages, Traffiques and Discoveries of the English Nation. Vol. 8. Glasgow: MacLehose, 1904. “The Second Voyage of Jaques Cartier” (Florio’s translation), the chapters on the sickness and the cure, pp. 245–250. Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/principalnavigat08hakl
- Trudel, Marcel. “Cartier, Jacques (1491–1557).” In Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 1. University of Toronto/Université Laval, 1966, revised 2014. The second voyage, the wintering, and the authorship of the accounts. https://www.biographi.ca/en/bio/cartier_jacques_1491_1557_1E.html
- Trudel, Marcel. “Donnacona.” In Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 1. University of Toronto/Université Laval, 1966, revised 1979. https://www.biographi.ca/en/bio/donnacona_1E.html
- Parks Canada. “Wintering (1535–1536).” Cartier-Brébeuf National Historic Site. On the crew’s food, the cold, and the dead. https://parks.canada.ca/lhn-nhs/qc/cartierbrebeuf/culture/histoire-history/evenement-event/cartier/c
- Bouchard, Julie. “L’histoire méconnue d’un arbre de vie.” ULaval nouvelles, November 4, 2009 (on Jacques Mathieu, L’Annedda: L’arbre de vie, Septentrion, 2009, which argues for balsam fir). https://nouvelles.ulaval.ca/2009/11/04/lhistoire-meconnue-dun-arbre-de-vie-bcdb4f929398e4390b6b993096acce60
- Rashdall, Hastings. The Universities of Europe in the Middle Ages. Vol. 2, part 1. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1895. Chap. 8, § 1, “Montpellier” (from p. 113, on its medical school), and chap. 9, § 9, “Louvain,” pp. 259–261. Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/universitiesofeu21rash
- Heyd, W. Histoire du commerce du Levant au moyen-âge. Edited by Furcy Raynaud. Vol. 2. Leipzig: Harrassowitz, 1886. P. 365 (Alexandria, “le grand marché cosmopolite,” and its spices) and p. 581 (Alexandria as the great market for benzoin). Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/heyd-histoire-du-commerce-du-levant-au-moyen-age-v-2
- Littré, É. Dictionnaire de la langue française. Vol. 4. Paris: Hachette, 1883. Entry “Vérole.” Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/dictionnairedela04littuoft
- The Catholic Encyclopedia. New York: Robert Appleton. Vol. 9 (1910), “Litany,” by Francis Mershman; vol. 12 (1911), “Psalms,” the section on their use in the liturgy (the penitential psalms). Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/catholicencyclop09char and https://archive.org/details/catholicencyclop0012unse